paperbot · PL 论文追踪

全部论文 待读 收藏

VidSumEval: A Web Platform and Benchmark for Evaluating AI-Generated Programming Video Summaries

VidSumEval:用于评估AI生成的编程视频摘要的Web平台与基准
ASE Proceedings of the 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering2026引用 0 inbox
Osama AlGhamdi, Ameer AlGhamdi, Faisal Alorabi, Mohammad D. Alahmadi, Abdulmalik Alzahrani, Abdullah Almazroui
crossref: 2026-10-09

AI 速览

一句话:提出VidSumEval——面向学习效果的AI生成编程教学视频摘要评估平台与基准,并配以用户研究验证。

YouTube上的编程教程视频是常用学习资源,但篇幅过长使复习效率低下。AI摘要工具可生成更短版本,但现有评估几乎只用相似度指标衡量表面重叠,无法判断摘要是否真正支持学习。为此,作者提出VidSumEval:一个从以学习为中心视角评估AI生成编程教程摘要的Web平台与基准。基准含C、Java、Python的10个教程,配套VEED与NotebookLM生成的摘要及自动生成理解测验,并支持提交新教程离线评审。作者以被试内研究(n=20)测量测验理解与完整性、清晰性、连贯性评分,并用摘要与原视频的测验分差报告学习效果。

问题
现有AI视频摘要评估几乎完全依赖相似度指标,只能衡量表面文本重叠,无法反映摘要是否真正帮助学习者理解编程内容。
方法
构建VidSumEval Web平台与基准:收录C、Java、Python共10个教程、两个商用引擎(VEED、NotebookLM)的摘要与自动生成理解测验,并支持用户提交新YouTube教程进行离线评审。
评估
通过被试内用户研究(n=20)评估,结合基于测验的理解得分与完整性、清晰性、连贯性的Likert评分,并以每位参与者在摘要视频与原视频上的测验分差衡量学习效果。
原文摘要(Abstract)

Programming tutorial videos on YouTube are a widely used learning resource, but their length often makes content review inefficient. AI-based summarization tools can produce shorter versions of these videos, yet existing evaluation relies almost exclusively on similarity-based metrics that measure surface overlap rather than whether the summaries actually support learning. We present VidSumEval, a web platform and benchmark for evaluating AI-generated programming tutorial summaries from a learning-centered perspective. The benchmark pairs 10 tutorials in C, Java, and Python with summaries from two commercial engines (VEED and NotebookLM) and auto-generated comprehension quizzes; users can also submit new YouTube tutorials for offline review. We validate the benchmark with a within-subject study (n=20) measuring both quiz-based comprehension and Likert-scale ratings on completeness, clarity, and coherence; learning effectiveness is reported as the per-participant difference between summarized- and original-video quiz scores. The platform is available at https://progsumeval.onrender.com; the source code and dataset are archived at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21763079; and the screencast is available at https://youtu.be/iBB-5HfRVSk.

链接与引用

DOI 原文 · PDF(开放获取) ·

BibTeX
@inproceedings{paperbot12546,
  title = {VidSumEval: A Web Platform and Benchmark for Evaluating AI-Generated Programming Video Summaries},
  author = {Osama AlGhamdi and Ameer AlGhamdi and Faisal Alorabi and Mohammad D. Alahmadi and Abdulmalik Alzahrani and Abdullah Almazroui},
  booktitle = {ASE},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1145/3832783.3834594}
}