paperbot · PL 论文追踪

全部论文 待读 收藏

P2 Internal and Observational Parametricity for Cubical Agda

Cubical Agda 的内部参数性与观察式参数性
POPL 8(POPL)2024匹配度 3/10 · 该论文属于类型论与证明助手的基础研究,虽然涉及形式化验证和定理证明,但未涉及用户核心关注的LLM/Agent与静态分析/形式化验证的交叉、浮点或贝叶斯程序分析,也没有AI/LLM作为工具或对象。引用 2 inbox
Antoine Van Muylder, Andreas Nuyts, Dominique Devriese
crossref: 2026-09-10

AI 速览

一句话:提出首个实用的内部参数性证明助手 Agda--bridges,并基于 SRP 给出内部自由定理的单行证明。

参数性翻译能从单个多态程序计算参数性陈述与证明,但不提供内部参数性;内部参数性类型论虽可导出内部参数性,却缺乏成熟证明助手实现,证明低层繁琐。本文提出 Agda--bridges:首个实用的内部参数性证明助手,首次机器化证明相对性定理等关键定理。作者类比 HoTT/UF 的结构同一原理(SIP),提出结构相关性原理(SRP)作为内部参数性的高层充分条件,并对满足 SRP 的类型证明一般参数性定理,从而单行证明标准内部自由定理。还指出 SRP 比 SIP 更难证明,并在 Agda--bridges 中浅层嵌入逻辑关系的观察式类型论以组合满足 SRP 的类型;该定理应为其推理规则之一。

问题
如何在依赖类型证明助手中同时获得内部参数性与可用的机器化证明,弥补参数性翻译缺乏内部参数性、内部参数性类型论缺乏成熟实现与高层证明手段的空白。
方法
提出 Agda--bridges 证明助手,机器化验证相对性定理等,并提出结构相关性原理(SRP)与满足 SRP 类型的一般参数性定理;还浅层嵌入逻辑关系的观察式类型论来组合这类类型。
评估
在 Agda--bridges 中给出关键定理的机器化证明,并用参数性定理单行证明标准内部自由定理;同时讨论 SRP 相对 SIP 的证明难度与嵌入类型论的规则地位。
原文摘要(Abstract)

Two approaches exist to incorporate parametricity into proof assistants based on dependent type theory. On the one hand, parametricity translations conveniently compute parametricity statements and their proofs solely based on individual well-typed polymorphic programs. But they do not offer internal parametricity: formal proofs that any polymorphic program of a certain type satisfies its parametricity statement. On the other hand, internally parametric type theories augment plain type theory with additional primitives out of which internal parametricity can be derived. But those type theories lack mature proof assistant implementations and deriving parametricity in them involves low-level intractable proofs. In this paper, we contribute Agda --bridges: the first practical internally parametric proof assistant. We provide the first mechanized proofs of crucial theorems for internal parametricity, like the relativity theorem. We identify a high-level sufficient condition for proving internal parametricity which we call the structure relatedness principle (SRP) by analogy with the structure identity principle (SIP) of HoTT/UF. We state and prove a general parametricity theorem for types that satisfy the SRP. Our parametricity theorem lets us obtain one-liner proofs of standard internal free theorems. We observe that the SRP is harder to prove than the SIP and provide in Agda --bridges a shallowly embedded type theory to compose types that satisfy the SRP. This type theory is an observational type theory of logical relations and our parametricity theorem ought to be one of its inference rules.

链接与引用

DOI 原文 · PDF(开放获取) ·

BibTeX
@article{paperbot2589,
  title = {Internal and Observational Parametricity for Cubical Agda},
  author = {Antoine Van Muylder and Andreas Nuyts and Dominique Devriese},
  journal = {Proceedings of the ACM on Programming Languages},
  volume = {8},
  number = {POPL},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1145/3632850}
}