一句话:大规模实证研究揭示 Android 应用普遍存在可访问性问题,开发者缺乏意识且应用商店评分无法反映问题程度。
移动应用已成为日常生活的重要组成部分,对约占全球人口 15% 的残障人士而言,能否顺畅使用应用尤为关键。本文从三个互补视角对 Android 应用的可访问性展开大规模实证研究:首先分析超过 1000 个 Android 应用,发现几乎所有应用都存在可访问性问题,严重阻碍残障用户使用;其次通过开发者调查探究问题根源,发现开发者普遍不了解可访问性设计原则与分析工具,其所在组织也未给予可访问性足够重视;最后考察应用商店的用户评分与评论,发现由于残障用户比例偏低,评分和应用流行度并不能反映可访问性问题的严重程度。文章最后总结若干观察,为未来研究与开发奠定基础。
Mobile apps are an integral component of our daily life. Ability to use mobile apps is important for everyone, but arguably even more so for approximately 15% of the world population with disabilities. This paper presents the results of a large-scale empirical study aimed at understanding accessibility of Android apps from three complementary perspectives. First, we analyze the prevalence of accessibility issues in over 1, 000 Android apps. We find that almost all apps are riddled with accessibility issues, hindering their use by disabled people. We then investigate the developer sentiments through a survey aimed at understanding the root causes of so many accessibility issues. We find that in large part developers are unaware of accessibility design principles and analysis tools, and the organizations in which they are employed do not place a premium on accessibility. We finally investigate user ratings and comments on app stores. We find that due to the disproportionately small number of users with disabilities, user ratings and app popularity are not indicative of the extent of accessibility issues in apps. We conclude the paper with several observations that form the foundation for future research and development.