Automatic program repair (APR) regularly faces the challenge of overfitting patches - patches that pass the test suite, but do not actually address the problems when evaluated manually. Currently, overfit detection requires manual inspection or an oracle making quality control of APR an expensive task. With this work, we want to introduce properties in addition to unit tests for APR to address the problem of overfitting. To that end, we design and implement PROPR, a program repair tool for Haskell that leverages both property-based testing (via QuickCheck) and the rich type sys-tem and synthesis offered by the Haskell compiler. We compare the repair-ratio, time-to-first-patch and overfitting-ratio when using unit tests, property-based tests, and their combination. Our results show that properties lead to quicker results and have a lower overfit ratio than unit tests. The created overfit patches provide valuable insight into the underlying problems of the program to repair (e.g., in terms of fault localization or test quality). We consider this step towards fitter, or at least insightful, patches a critical contribution to bring APR into developer workflows.

@inproceedings{GissurarsonAPDS22,
  title = {PropR},
  author = {Matthías Páll Gissurarson and Leonhard Applis and Annibale Panichella and Arie van Deursen and David Sands},
  booktitle = {ICSE},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1145/3510003.3510620}
}