paperbot · PL 论文追踪

全部论文 待读 收藏

P2 The Blurred Drinker Paradox: Constructive Reverse Mathematics of the Downward Löwenheim-Skolem Theorem

模糊的饮酒者悖论:向下 Löwenheim-Skolem 定理的构造性反推数学
LICS 2025 40th Annual ACM/IEEE Symposium on Logic in Computer Science (LICS)2025匹配度 2/10 · 论文属于构造性反推数学与数理逻辑基础研究,核心是向下Löwenheim-Skolem定理、选择公理与新提出的模糊饮酒者悖论之间的等价性分解,与用户关注的程序静态分析、LLM/Agent、浮点或贝叶斯程序分析几乎没有直接交集。仅其附带的Coq形式化开发与'定理证明与证明工程'标签与形式化验证方向有极弱的边缘关联,但不涉及LLM或程序分析工具。引用 0 inbox
Dominik Kirst, Haoyi Zeng
crossref: 2026-09-12

AI 速览

一句话:在构造性反推数学中精细分解向下Löwenheim-Skolem定理,提出模糊饮酒者悖论BDP并刻画其与选择公理的关系。

本文在构造性反推数学下重新审视一阶逻辑的向下Löwenheim-Skolem(DLS)定理:每个无限模型都有可数初等子模型。经典基底下该定理等价于依赖选择公理(DC);作者通过构造性分析给出更细的逻辑分解:在可数选择(CC)下,DLS等价于DC与新识别的排中律片段——模糊饮酒者悖论(BDP)——的合取;不假设CC时,DLS等价于BDP与DC、CC的模糊弱化形式的合取。作者还独立研究BDP与模糊选择公理,表明BDP是不依赖Markov原理的LEM、模糊DC是不依赖CC的DC。结果伴随Coq机器化开发。

问题
在构造性反推数学中,确定一阶逻辑向下Löwenheim-Skolem定理需要哪些选择与排中原理,并细化其经典等价于依赖选择公理的结果。
方法
采用构造性反推数学,引入模糊饮酒者悖论(BDP)与模糊选择公理,分离可数选择、依赖选择与排中律片段,并在Coq中机器化验证。
评估
通过伴随的Coq开发形式化验证等价与分解定理,并在有/无可数选择等不同假设下比较DLS、DC、CC与BDP。
原文摘要(Abstract)

In the setting of constructive reverse mathematics, we analyse the downward Löwenheim-Skolem (DLS) theorem of first-order logic, stating that every infinite model has a countable elementary submodel. Refining the well-known equivalence of the DLS theorem to the axiom of dependent choice (DC) over classical base theories, our constructive approach allows for several finer logical decompositions: Just assuming countable choice (CC), the DLS theorem is equivalent to the conjunction of DC with a newly identified fragment of the excluded middle (LEM) that we call the blurred drinker paradox (BDP). Further without CC, the DLS theorem is equivalent to the conjunction of BDP with similarly blurred weakenings of DC and CC. Independently of their connection with the DLS theorem, we also study BDP and the blurred choice axioms on their own, for instance by showing that BDP is LEM without a contribution of Markov's principle and that blurred DC is DC without a contribution of CC. The paper is hyperlinked with an accompanying Coq development.

链接与引用

DOI 原文 ·

BibTeX
@inproceedings{paperbot8659,
  title = {The Blurred Drinker Paradox: Constructive Reverse Mathematics of the Downward Löwenheim-Skolem Theorem},
  author = {Dominik Kirst and Haoyi Zeng},
  booktitle = {LICS},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1109/lics65433.2025.00073}
}