一句话:首次系统研究 Apollo 与 Autoware 障碍物检测的延迟,并提出 ADPerf 生成点云测试用例以暴露延迟升高。
障碍物检测是自动驾驶系统运行的关键环节,其延迟直接影响安全性,但该模块的延迟表现及对 LiDAR 点云数据变化的鲁棒性尚缺乏理解。本文首次对两款工业级自动驾驶系统 Apollo 与 Autoware 的障碍物检测模块进行综合测量与性能建模研究。基于该研究的发现,作者提出 ADPerf:一个生成真实点云数据测试用例的工具,用于暴露更高的检测延迟。作者将 ADPerf 用于对自动驾驶系统中广泛使用的 3D 障碍物检测模块进行压力测试,并进一步考察这些测试对下游轨迹预测模块的传播效应。评估表明,对障碍物检测组件(尤其是 3D 障碍物检测)进行性能测试十分必要,它们可能成为系统延迟升高的主要瓶颈;这种负面影响还会传播至其他模块,降低自动驾驶系统的整体可靠性。
Obstacle detection is crucial to the operation of autonomous driving systems, which rely on multiple sensors, such as cameras and LiDARs, combined with code logic and deep learning models to detect obstacles for time-sensitive decisions. Consequently, obstacle detection latency is critical to the safety and effectiveness of autonomous driving systems. However, the latency of the obstacle detection module and its resilience to various changes in the LiDAR point cloud data are not yet fully understood. In this work, we present the first comprehensive investigation on measuring and modeling the performance of the obstacle detection modules in two industry-grade autonomous driving systems, i.e., Apollo and Autoware. Learning from this investigation, we introduce ADPerf, a tool that aims to generate realistic point cloud data test cases that can expose increased detection latency. Increasing latency decreases the availability of the detected obstacles and stresses the capabilities of subsequent modules in autonomous driving systems, i.e., the modules may be negatively impacted by the increased latency in obstacle detection.We applied ADPerf to stress-test the performance of widely used 3D obstacle detection modules in autonomous driving systems, as well as the propagation of such tests on trajectory prediction modules. Our evaluation highlights the need to conduct performance testing of obstacle detection components, especially 3D obstacle detection, as they can be a major bottleneck to increased latency of the autonomous driving system. Such an adverse outcome will also further propagate to other modules, reducing the overall reliability of autonomous driving systems.
DOI 原文 ·
@inproceedings{paperbot9420,
title = {ADPerf: Investigating and Testing Performance in Autonomous Driving Systems},
author = {Tri Minh-Triet Pham and Diego Elias Costa and Weiyi Shang and Jinqiu Yang},
booktitle = {ASE},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.1109/ase63991.2025.00143}
}